Transformation of Preservice and New Teacher Literacy Identity: Three Transactional Dimensions
AuthorSpitler, Ellen J.
Keywordscontent area literacy
teacher literacy identity
teacher professional development
AdvisorAnders, Patricia L.
Committee ChairAnders, Patricia L.
MetadataShow full item record
PublisherThe University of Arizona.
RightsCopyright © is held by the author. Digital access to this material is made possible by the University Libraries, University of Arizona. Further transmission, reproduction or presentation (such as public display or performance) of protected items is prohibited except with permission of the author.
AbstractAdolescent literacy is currently viewed as in crisis. Moore (2002) argues that a focus on adolescent literate identity seems to be a key consideration when designing literacy instruction for secondary classrooms. This dissertation argues that in order for adolescents to develop a literate identity, their teachers should possess a literate identity.This phenomenological case study investigates the transformational paths nine developing teachers traversed as they "authored" their teacher literacy identity through a university content area literacy course, student teaching, and/or the induction period. "Authoring" includes both how the teachers represent their literacy identities in their writing and speaking, and how teachers do their literacy identities when enacting or performing (Moje, 2004) literacy instruction.Six instructional engagements completed by participants when they were students in a university content area literacy course comprise one data set. During student teaching and/or during their first or second year of teaching, three types of data were gathered: the Seidman (1998) three-interview series; a content area literacy lesson planning session; and an observation of each planned lesson. A phenomenological analysis (Merriam, 1998) guided the initial examination of the data. The data sets were analyzed using the constant comparative method (Bogdan & Biklen, 2007; Merriam, 1998).Teacher literacy identity is a previously unexplored construct. Based on a literature review and the voices of the participants, the following definition took shape: teacher literacy identity is a confident view of self as responsible for and in control of improving the literacy learning of self and the competency to enact engagements to guide the literacy learning of students. Teacher literacy identity consists of three transactional dimensions: the construct of literacy, the construct of literacy in practice, and the quality of the literacy enactment. Six major categories emerged to illustrate the phenomenon: identity, learning communities, personal agency, design of practice, literacy theories, and sources of dissonance.Implications of this exploration suggest that the investigation and documentation of developing teachers' literacy learning trajectories are worthy areas of further study. Moreover, a critical re-evaluation of teacher education and professional development in the support of teacher literacy identity deserves close attention.
Degree ProgramLanguage, Reading & Culture
Degree GrantorUniversity of Arizona
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Textbook Literacies - Investigating the Potential of Commercial Textbooks for Literacies-Oriented Instruction and the Professional Development of Graduate StudentsWarner, Chantelle; Lange, Kristin; Dupuy, Beatrice; Reinhardt, Jonathon (The University of Arizona., 2018)In recent years, there have been urgent calls to reform foreign language (FL) curricula in efforts to unite objectives, content, and methods of all levels of FL instruction and do away with program bifurcation and dichotomous thinking (Swaffar & Arens 2005, MLA Ad Hoc Committee 2007, Crane et al. 2011). Literacy and literacy-oriented approaches have been suggested as frameworks to curricular design and teaching practice that could overcome this bifurcation. Literacy, traditionally understood as the ability to read and write, becomes plural in these approaches and is understood as a wide-array of community-based social practices (Knobel & Lankshear 2007). Literacy-oriented teaching (Kern 2000, Allen, Paesani, & Dupuy 2016), combining communication, analysis, interpretation, and reflection, promotes more nuanced attention to written language, as well as more critical awareness of language use. So far only a few FL programs have redesigned their curricula guided by literacy-oriented principles, and especially integrating literacies into introductory levels has been identified as challenging. Allen and Paesani (2010) consider several obstacles to the implementation of literacy-oriented pedagogy in lower-level courses relating to common teaching methods at these levels, content and material that is often driven by commercial textbooks, and graduate students’ professional development. The studies in this dissertation investigate these obstacles framing them with textbook content and use. A comprehensive literature review revisits communicative and literacies-oriented approaches to FL teaching to provide an account of how they are both similar and different. I then discuss the potential of textbooks for literacy-oriented pedagogy from three angles. In an analysis of three common introductory German textbooks for the college level, I examined frequency and range of texts, and evaluated which language teaching approach the activities accompanying the texts supported, in order to assess in how far they can lay the groundwork for literacy-based instruction. Based on this analysis, I designed an autoethnographic classroom-based research study investigating what the use of textbooks within literacies pedagogy could look like. This chapter describes several pedagogical interventions that made active use of textbook material, but reframed it drawing on the concepts of “design pedagogy”, Kalantzis and Cope’s knowledge processes, and recent work on teacher reflexivity. In the third study, I report on several training initiatives that guided first-semester graduate students teaching beginning German without much prior teaching experience and with a common textbook. Targeting their professional development in the first semester, data collected through discussion posts, reflective journals, and lesson plans shed light on novice graduate student instructors’ ability to connect textbook use in their classrooms with their growing conceptual understanding of teaching methods. All three studies investigate if and how textbooks can become an active component of implementing literacies-oriented pedagogy at the introductory level.
The Effects Of Targeted, Connectivism-Based Information Literacy Instruction On Latino Students Information Literacy Skills And Library Usage BehaviorHeidorn, Bryan; Czerkawski, Betul; Walsh, John Barry; Heidorn, Bryan; Czerkawski, Betul; Fricke, Martin; Kjos, Glen; Sun, Heshan (The University of Arizona., 2013)The United States is experiencing a socio-demographic shift in population and education. Latinos are the fastest growing segment of the population on the national level and in higher education. The Latino student population growth rate and Latino college completion rate are not reciprocal. While Latino students are the fastest growing demographic group in higher education, they continue to have the lowest persistence and retention rates. Latino students are more at risk for dropping out of college than any other ethnic group. Latinos decreasing persistence rates have caused an academic achievement gap in higher education (Long, 2011). Literature has correlated the gap with Latinos limited IL competency and low library usage (Long, 2011).This quasi-experimental research examined the effects of a targeted information literacy (IL) instructional method on Latino community college students IL skills and library usage. The study also introduced the idea of using a connectivism based targeted instruction to influence Latinos IL skills and library usage. The intent of the study was to investigate the development of information literacy instruction (ILI) which targets Latino students and uses the principles of connectivism. Connectivism posits that students' learn by connecting to information along their personal learning networks (Siemens, 2005). Connectivism helps position the library within Latino students' personal learning networks. This positioning may increase their library usage and by extension their IL skills. Specifically, this quantitative study assessed the effect of the instruction on IL skills and library usage behavior of Latino community college students. A pretest/posttest control group design was used for this study. A sample of 92 Latino male and female students completed the pretest and posttest. They were recruited from a diverse population of community college students who were registered for Introductory English classes. Data was collected through instrumentation that included an Information Literacy Rubric, an Information Literacy Skills Test, a Library Usage Survey/Demographic Identification Form, and a Citation Analysis Form. Though two of the hypotheses were not supported, the data collected allowed the researcher to accomplish two of the purposes of this study, to design and assess a targeted ILI that increases Latino students' IL skills and library usage, and to advance the research that grounds the emerging learning theory of connectivism. The more connections students made to information sources the higher their overall IL skill score were. This data suggests that as students make connections to information resources they are learning IL skills and the more sources they connect to, the more they learn. Though TI did not emerge as the more effective method, it is effective at increasing library usage and IL skills in Latino community college students'. The results of this study may lead to a better understanding of how students acquire IL skills. Instruction has become increasingly important in librarianship and recently has even eclipsed traditional reference service. (Grassian & Kaplowitz, xix, 2009). More and more academic libraries are being held accountable for their contribution to student learning. The findings of this study provide evidence that the instructional efforts of the library are influencing student learning outcomes.
Literacy Connections: Early Literacy Interventions for Young Children from At-Risk PopulationsMaker, Carol June; Robinson, Felicia Amelia; Maker, Carol June; Taylor, John L.; Liaupsin, Carl J.; Pirtle, Jody M. (The University of Arizona., 2014)Children who have experienced developmental, social, or economic risks may benefit more from attending high-quality preschool intervention programs than their more advantaged peers; thus, programs that have delivered high-quality experiences may have served as a protective factor for these children to help reduce the achievement gap that has existed at school entry. The overarching purpose of this dissertation was to examine best practice in providing systemic early literacy interventions as a protective factor against school failure for young at-risk children. The three studies comprising this dissertation included analyses of systemic early literacy interventions for young children at risk of reading and school failure due to (a) developmental delays, (b) low socioeconomic status, or (c) English language learner status. Consistent with previous literature, the researcher found that children participating in a responsive early literacy intervention program were better prepared for kindergarten than were non-participating peers. Responsive early literacy interventions were defined as purposeful instruction designed to meet the educational needs of children by implementing an embedded-explicit or balanced approach to teaching. Attendance in high-quality early education programs - especially for children from disadvantaged backgrounds - was linked to lasting effects on indicators related to student achievement.