CREATING HIGH-VALUE REAL-WORLD IMPACT THROUGH SYSTEMATIC PROGRAMS OF RESEARCH
AffiliationUniv Arizona, Eller Coll Management
IS research methodology
value of IS research
systematic high-impact research model
MetadataShow full item record
PublisherSOC INFORM MANAGE-MIS RES CENT
CitationNunamaker, J. F., Twyman, N. W., Giboney, J. S., & Briggs, R. O. (2017). CREATING HIGH-VALUE REAL-WORLD IMPACT THROUGH SYSTEMATIC PROGRAMS OF RESEARCH. MIS Quarterly, 41(2), 335-351.
RightsCopyright © of MIS Quarterly
Collection InformationThis item from the UA Faculty Publications collection is made available by the University of Arizona with support from the University of Arizona Libraries. If you have questions, please contact us at email@example.com.
AbstractAn ongoing conversation in the Information Systems literature addresses the concern, "How can we conduct research that makes a difference?" A shortage of high-impact research will, over time, challenge the identity and weaken the viability of IS as an academic discipline. This paper presents the systematic high-impact research model (SHIR), an approach to conducting high-impact research. SHIR embodies the insight gained from three streams of high-impact research programs spanning more than 50 years. The SHIR framework rests on the proposition that IS researchers can produce higher-impact contributions by developing long-term research programs around major real-world issues, as opposed to ad hoc projects addressing a small piece of a large problem. These persistent research programs focus on addressing the entirety of an issue, by leveraging multidisciplinary, multiuniversity research centers that employ a breadth of research methods and large-scale projects. To function effectively, SHIR programs must be sustained by academic and practitioner partnerships, research centers, and outreach activities. We argue that SHIR research programs increase the likelihood of high impact research.
Note60 month embargo; Published online: June 2017
VersionFinal published version
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Pineal-mediated inhibition of prolactin cell activity: Investigation of dopaminergic involvement.Burns, Danny Michael. (The University of Arizona., 1989)The purpose of these studies was to determine whether the inhibitory effects of short photoperiod exposure on prolactin cell activity in male Syrian hamsters and/or the inhibitory effects of melatonin treatment on the growth and activity of diethylstilbestrol- (DES) induced prolactinomas in Fisher 344 (F344) rats were possibly mediated through alterations in dopaminergic regulatory mechanisms. In both the hamster and the rat, changes in hypothalamic dopamine neuronal activity and changes in pituitary responsiveness to dopamine have been suggested as possible mechanisms in the prolactin-inhibitory effects of light deprivation or melatonin administration. The present studies in the male Syrian hamster addressed two issues. First, it was of interest to determine if anterior pituitaries of long photoperiod-exposed male hamsters possess dopamine receptors, which are presumably necessary for responsiveness to dopamine. This was accomplished by analysis of ³H-spiperone binding to anterior pituitary membranes. Second, possible changes in pituitary sensitivity to dopamine were assessed by comparison of dose response curves for the inhibition by dopamine of prolactin release from hemipituitaries incubated in vitro from both long and short photoperiod-exposed animals over a series of time points from three to fifteen weeks. In the second series of experiments, adult female F344 rats received daily injection of melatonin or saline vehicle. After two weeks, half of the animals were sacrificed for analysis of ³H-spiperone binding to anterior pituitary membranes, measurement of hypothalamic dopamine turnover and analysis of in vitro pituitary sensitivity to dopamine. The remaining animals received subcutaneous implants containing DES and injections were continued on the same schedule until sacrifice four weeks later for measurement of the same parameters. In both the hamster and rat models, treatments exerted profound inhibitory effects on indices of prolactin cell activity. However, these studies provide no evidence for the involvement of altered dopaminergic regulation in the production of such effects. Neither pituitary sensitivity to dopamine in vitro nor hypothalamic dopamine neuronal activity was enhanced by short photoperiod exposure or melatonin treatment. Prolactin-inhibitory effects of these treatments appear to be mediated through as yet unidentified dopamine-independent mechanisms.
The relationship between classroom participation structures and fourth-grade Guamanian students' reading comprehension.Allen, Adela A.; Salas, Marilyn Camacho; Moll, Luis C.; Goodman, Yetta M.; Mitchell, Judy N. (The University of Arizona., 1991)The purpose of this study was to explore the relationship between lesson interaction patterns and fourth-grade Guamanian students' reading comprehension. In the last decade, a variety of new approaches have emerged in the field of education that extend our ability to better understand the teaching-learning process. These approaches allow close and detailed examination of how teachers and their students interact in creating classroom settings, particularly as they refer to reading lessons. The present study continued the investigation of classroom participation structures and their relationship to reading comprehension in a multilingual and multicultural setting. Three reading discussion lessons were observed and audio- and videotaped in four, fourth-grade classrooms in Guam during the months of November 1989 to April 1990. Of the three discussion lessons, one was selected for in depth analyses. Students were in the Level 11 reading group of the Silver Burdette-Ginn Basal Reader Series. Teachers were instructed to teach their lessons according to their usual procedures. No attempt was made to alter delivery of instruction. From transcriptions of the audio- and videotapes, Mehan's (1979) procedures were used to describe turn-allocation and speech act procedures. In addition, retellings were analyzed utilizing the retelling profile developed by Mitchell and Irwin (1991). Although the study was conducted in schools with bilingual, multicultural and multilingual teachers and students, the participation structures found in these Guam classrooms appear no different from the participation structures found in most American classrooms. In terms of the questions being explored in this dissertation, sensitivity to the linguistic and cultural background of Guamanian students was not evident. The results of the qualitative and quantitative analyses of the data pointed to three major findings. First, variability existed in the participation structures found in the four, fourth-grade reading discussion lessons. Second, there were minimal differences in participation structures when teachers who adhered closely to basal reader material and instruction were compared with teachers who did not adhere as closely to basal reader material and instruction. Third, the study suggests that the participation structures found in the four, fourth-grade reading discussion lessons were related to the reading comprehension of these fourth-grade Guamanian students.
Information, auditing, and incentives in regulation.Isaac, R. Mark; Cech, Paula-Ann.; Reynolds, Stanley R.; Smith, Vernon L.; Conn, David (The University of Arizona., 1989)This dissertation uses laboratory economic experiments to test the incentive effects of regulatory policies and practices under asymmetric information conditions. Significant results and policy implications are obtained on the traditional use of rate-of-return regulation (RORR) to regulate natural monopolies, and on the practice of restricting such firms from entering ancillary markets. The objective of the first several chapters is to test the incentive effects of RORR on market performance. Results confirm long-standing theories of incentive malfunctions of RORR. One result shows that under voluntary compliance, RORR is completely ineffective for regulating single sellers when cost information is private to firms, allowing them to misrepresent costs and earn monopoly profits. When firm's do not know market demand, they capture less surplus, but still earn above RORR expected returns. When stochastic auditing is added varying penalty rates and audit probabilities, significant cost overestimates remain common. Theoretical analysis explains the potential source of this anomaly as being the use of historical cost information in rate setting when excess profits are used as the audit benchmark. Other results show that in perfect repeated static implementations of RORR, wasteful input use will occur manifested as rate base padding or Averch-Johnson type selection of inefficient input combinations. Another chapter addresses the consequences of deregulating RORR franchise firms allowing them to enter ancillary markets. A stylized model of the telecommunications industry is created and experimentally tested to determine if anti-competitive firm behavior results when entry restrictions are lifted. Results offer no support for the arguments that regulated firms will use monopoly market earnings to underwrite ancillary market operations ("deep pocket"), engage in predatory pricing, or unfair competition. Economic arguments for removing entry barriers to improve market performance (increased output and lower prices) are substantiated.