Competition Among Proprietary and Open-Source Software Firms: The Role of Licensing in Strategic Contribution
AffiliationEller College of Management, University of Arizona
Software services market
Strategic contributions to open-source software
MetadataShow full item record
CitationAugust, T., Chen, W., & Zhu, K. (2020). Competition Among Proprietary and Open-Source Software Firms: The Role of Licensing in Strategic Contribution. Management Science.
RightsCopyright © 2020, INFORMS
Collection InformationThis item from the UA Faculty Publications collection is made available by the University of Arizona with support from the University of Arizona Libraries. If you have questions, please contact us at email@example.com.
AbstractIn enterprise software markets, firms are increasingly using services-based business models built on open-source software (OSS) to compete with established, proprietary software firms. Because third-party firms can also strategically contribute to OSS and compete in the services market, the nature of competition between OSS constituents and proprietary software firms can be complex. Moreover, their incentives are likely influenced by the licensing schemes that govern OSS. We study a three-player game and examine how open-source licensing affects competition among an open-source originator, an open-source contributor, and a proprietor competing in an enterprise software market. In this regard, we examine (1) how quality investments and prices are endogenously determined in equilibrium, (2) how license restrictiveness impacts equilibrium investments and the quality of offerings, and (3) how license restrictiveness affects consumer surplus and social welfare. Although some in the open-source community often advocate restrictive licenses such as theGNUGeneral Public License because it is not always in the best interest of the originator for the contributor to invest greater development effort, such licensing can actually be detrimental to both consumer surplus and social welfare when it exacerbates this incentive conflict. We find such an outcome in markets characterized by software providers with similar development capabilities yet cast in favor of the proprietor. In contrast, when these capabilities either become more dispersed or remain similar but tilt in favor of open source, a more restrictive license instead encourages greater effort from the OSS contributor, leads to higher OSS quality, and provides a larger societal benefit. © 2020 INFORMS.
Note12 month embargo; published online: 05 October 2020
VersionFinal accepted manuscript
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Open Source Software for Creation of Digital Library: A Comparative Study of Greenstone Digital Library Software & DSpaceRandhawa, Sukhwinder (Red Flower Publication Pvt. Ltd., 2012-12)Softwares now-a-days have become the life line of modern day organizations. Organizations cannot think of doing their tasks effectively and efficiently without softwares. The extremely competitive environment, zero deficiency and enhanced productivity has made it mandatory for the organizations to carefully choose the appropriate software after comprehensive needs assessment. Softwares simply their tasks and saves a lot of precious time which can be utilized in managing other important issues. Libraries also need softwares if they want to create a parallel digital library with features which we may not find in a traditional library. There are several open source softwares available to create a digital library. For this, firstly the library professionals should be aware of the advantages of open source software and should involve in their development. They should have basic knowledge about the selection, installation and maintenance. Open source software requires a greater degree of computing responsibility than commercial software. Digitization involves huge money to create and maintain and the OSS appears to be a means to reduce it. Among these, DSpace and Greenstone are becoming more popular in India and abroad. This paper deals with the comparison of these two popular OSS from various points of view. The comparative table may help the professionals who are planning to create a digital library.
LINKING DATA REDUCTION SOFTWARE TO AIRBORNE DATA ACQUISITION SOFTWARETrover, William F.; Teledyne Controls (International Foundation for Telemetering, 1984-10)With the incorporation of microprocessors providing dynamic control capability in flight test data acquisition and telemetry systems, software is now becoming a critical part of the airborne data system. Software importance generally appears to be underestimated by many users of the airborne systems, as until now they have only had to worry about programming a PCM data cycle map into EPROMs and plugging them into the airborne hardware. With newer programmable systems using microcomputers with E²PROM and RAM to provide a realtime EU display and control capability, airborne software can become a critical link in scheduling. Programming requirements for realtime data display and control in these data acquisition systems now makes it essential that there be software configuration control and a software (firmware) link between the data reduction software residing in the ground station and the data acquisition software in the aircraft. This paper addresses one solution to this new class of problem in flight test.