Sensitivity comparison of a NURBS freeform telescope

Abstract

We compare the optical performance, alignment sensitivity, and thermal stability of a Non-Uniform Rational B-Spline (NURBS) freeform telescope design to two more conventional design forms with the goal of facilitating acceptance of this new optical surface for aerospace applications. We present the designs of three three-mirror anastigmat (TMA) wide field (4°) telescopes with identical first order optical design parameters. These TMAs consist of a conventional design using off-axis aspheric mirrors, a freeform design using off-axis Zernike polynomial surfaces, and a freeform design using NURBS surfaces. Of the three, the NURBS design gives the best image quality and lowest geometrical design residual. The three designs have similar misalignment sensitivities and sensitivity to thermal soaks, countering a common misconception that freeform designs are more sensitive to misalignment than conventional designs. © 2023 SPIE. All rights reserved.